Allergens & Safety

Gentle Cleansing Gel or ClarityWell Charcoal? One Is Three Times the Price Per Ounce

We sell two facial cleansers. They are not interchangeable, and the size difference is bigger than it looks on the shelf.

The value comparison nobody does

Gentle Cleansing Gel ClarityWell Charcoal
Price $24.99 $19.90
Size 6 fl oz (177 ml) 2 oz (59 ml)
Per ounce ≈ $4.17 ≈ $9.95
Fragrance-free? Yes Contains tea tree oil
Best for Sensitive skin, daily use, post-procedure Oilier skin, travel, a compact bottle

ClarityWell costs nearly two and a half times as much per ounce. It is cheaper on the shelf because the bottle is a third of the size. That does not make it a bad product — at 2 oz it is a genuinely good travel or gym-bag size — but if you are buying a daily cleanser for home, the arithmetic matters.

EvenWell Gentle Cleansing Gel — $24.99, 6 fl oz

An oil-free gel, fragrance-free and sulfate-free, built around two mild surfactants: cocamidopropyl betaine and decyl glucoside. Those are the gentle end of the cleansing spectrum — not the stripping sulfates that leave skin squeaking.

Supporting ingredients: glycerin, panthenol (vitamin B5), sodium PCA and sodium lactate — all humectants that help skin hold moisture through a wash. Plus watermelon, apple and lentil fruit extracts, witch hazel water and licorice root extract.

This is the one to buy if: your skin is sensitive or reactive, you are using retinol and need a cleanser that will not add irritation, you are post-procedure, or you just want the lowest-risk daily wash.

Small note: alcohol appears low on the ingredient list. At that position it is a formulation aid, not the drying alcohol-heavy base of a traditional astringent.

ClarityWell Charcoal Facial Cleanser — $19.90, 2 oz

A rinse-off gel built on organic aloe vera leaf juice as the first ingredient — unusual, and a nice detail — with coconut-derived cleansing ingredients, vegetable glycerin, activated charcoal, tea tree oil and vitamin E.

Ten ingredients total. That is a short list for a cleanser.

Two cautions:

  • Tea tree oil is a recognised contact allergen for some people. If you have reacted to tea tree before, this is not your cleanser.
  • Pregnant or lactating people should consult a doctor before use — that instruction is on our own label for this product, and it is not on the Gentle Cleansing Gel.

What charcoal does, honestly

We are going to quote our own product page, because it is unusually straight:

"The cleanser does not detoxify the body or treat acne or another skin condition."

Activated charcoal is adsorbent — it binds things to its surface. In a rinse-off product it is on your face for perhaps thirty seconds. It helps lift surface oil and buildup during the wash, and that is the whole mechanism.

It does not pull toxins out of your pores, detox your skin, or treat acne. The same honest framing applies to our Charcoal Soap.

Which should you buy?

  • Daily cleanser at home, sensitive skin, best value: Gentle Cleansing Gel
  • Oilier skin, or you want a small bottle for travel or the gym: ClarityWell Charcoal
  • Using retinol or acids: Gentle Cleansing Gel — do not add tea tree on top of an active routine
  • Fragrance-sensitive: Gentle Cleansing Gel
  • Pregnant: Gentle Cleansing Gel, and check with your doctor either way

Both: for external use only, not to be ingested. Avoid contact with eyes. Discontinue use if irritation occurs. See the layering guide for where cleansing sits in a full routine.

Reading next

Leave a comment

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.