Two toners, same price ($26.99), same size (6 fl oz). The difference is what is in them and whose skin they suit.
First: this is not your grandmother's witch hazel
When people hear "witch hazel toner" they picture the drugstore astringent — the one that is largely alcohol, strips your face and leaves it tight. That product has put a lot of people off toners entirely.
Our Witch Hazel Pore Perfecting Toner is not that. The first ingredient is witch hazel leaf water — the distillate, not an alcohol-based astringent — and the formula is built around hydration rather than stripping:
- Sodium hyaluronate — hydration
- Glycerin, sodium PCA, sodium lactate, sorbitol, proline — humectants and skin's own moisture factors
- Radish root and bamboo leaf ferment filtrates
- Fructooligosaccharides — a prebiotic ingredient
Our own product description says it is "ideal for all skin types, especially dry or dehydrated skin" — which is the opposite of what the words "witch hazel toner" usually signal. Worth knowing before you rule it out.
Fragrance-free.
Gentle Balancing Toner — the calming one
Gentle Balancing Toner is aimed at sensitive or blemish-prone skin and post-procedure care. Its character comes from botanicals:
- Rosa damascena flower water (rose water) — the second ingredient
- Camellia sinensis (green tea) leaf extract
- Chamomile flower extract
- Aloe barbadensis leaf juice
- Allantoin — a well-established soothing ingredient
- Globularia alypum leaf extract
One honest flag
This one does not carry a fragrance-free badge, and the Witch Hazel toner does.
Rose water is naturally aromatic. That is not an added synthetic fragrance, and for most people it is a pleasant part of the product — but "fragrance-free" and "naturally scented by botanicals" are different things, and if your skin reacts to botanical aromatics, the fragrance-free option is the Witch Hazel one.
It also contains benzyl alcohol as a preservative, which a small number of people are sensitive to.
Chamomile is in the daisy family. If you have a ragweed or daisy-family allergy, be aware — chamomile also appears in our niacinamide serum and vitamin C serum.
Which one?
| If you… | Buy |
|---|---|
| Have dry or dehydrated skin | Witch Hazel |
| Need fragrance-free | Witch Hazel |
| Have sensitive or blemish-prone skin | Gentle Balancing |
| Are recovering from a procedure | Gentle Balancing |
| Like a rose scent | Gentle Balancing |
| React to botanical aromatics | Witch Hazel |
Do you even need a toner?
Honestly: no, not necessarily.
A toner is an optional step. If your routine is working with a cleanser, a serum and a moisturiser, adding a toner is not going to transform anything, and we would rather tell you that than sell you a fourth bottle.
Where a toner genuinely earns its place is as a light hydrating layer on damp skin before your serum — a humectant step that makes everything after it sit a little better. If your skin always feels slightly tight after cleansing, that is the gap a toner fills.
What a toner is not for, despite decades of marketing: "removing what the cleanser missed" (use a better cleanser) or "restoring pH" (your skin does that itself within about an hour).
How to use either
Apply to a cotton pad and sweep gently across face and neck after cleansing, or mist directly onto skin. Applying to slightly damp skin and following immediately with your serum gets more out of it.
Then your serums in order, then moisturiser, then sunscreen in the morning.
Both: for external use only, not to be ingested. Avoid contact with eyes. Discontinue use if irritation occurs. Neither treats acne, rosacea or any skin condition — both are cosmetic products.
Leave a comment
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.